From Stars to Sales: How Customer Reviews Are Redefining the In-Store Experience

By Greg Fournier | Last Updated: 25 March 2025

Customer reviews are no longer confined to e-commerce. They’re entering the physical retail space — on shelves, on tags, and right at the point of decision. This isn’t a gimmick. It’s a strategic move that smart brands are already leveraging.

Why it matters now

Reviews have broken out of the digital world. Today, you’ll find them on physical shelves, packaging, and even store displays. Why? Because while the setting may be offline, the behavior isn’t.

8 out of 10 shoppers check reviews on their phones while browsing in-store*. They want reassurance, fast. And when that moment happens, smart brands don’t let them leave the shelf — they bring the reviews to it.

What’s more, product pages with reviews convert 3.5x more than those without*. That same power is now being harnessed at the physical point of sale.

How brands are making it happen

Forward-thinking brands are embedding reviews directly into the in-store journey — and not just as a novelty, but as a core conversion lever.

Here’s how it looks in action:

Visual triggers: Star ratings printed on packaging and bold review quotes on danglers or shelf talkers give instant reassurance, right where it matters.

Deeper engagement: Review seals — like those used on Try & Review products — or QR codes linking to live feedback help convert interest into confidence, especially for high-involvement categories.

Here’s what that looks like in the real world:

undefined

Seen in-store: Try & Review seal featured on a Tefal product stand — “9 in 10 would recommend” instantly signals trust and customer endorsement.

Take the Amazon 4-Star Stores as a standout example. These physical locations stock only highly rated items, with in-store review cards prominently featuring customer feedback. It’s not just about visibility — it’s about giving feedback a starring role in the purchase decision. “Fun and easy to shop,” says Amazon — and it shows.

And it pays off: when brands display ratings and reviews on a product, it increases the conversion. Products with positive reviews send a clear message: shoppers are satisfied — and satisfaction leads to repeat purchases*.

How to bring it in-store:

Start simple: add star ratings or review quotes to shelf talkers to provide instant trust cues.

Boost credibility with visual badges, like Try & Review’s seal — quick to read, hard to ignore.

Need more depth? QR codes on packaging can link straight to verified reviews in one scan.

To keep things fresh, highlight a “top review of the month” in-store — a great way to spotlight your community.

And don’t forget to close the loop: invite shoppers to share their own reviews, right at the shelf.

Beyond reassurance: activating your community

In-store reviews don’t just build trust — they build belonging. By surfacing real voices in real-world spaces, you spotlight the community behind your brand. A customer who sees their words on a tag or shelf talker isn’t just validated — they’re empowered. That sense of recognition turns buyers into contributors, and contributors into advocates.

One Try & Review campaign showed this dynamic in full effect: reviews showcased on-pack (“9 in 10 would recommend”) led to a spike in both engagement and resell rates. It’s proof that reviews don’t have to stay online to drive results — and that community-powered retail is very much a thing.

undefined

Try & Review in action: This in-store campaign for Tefal turns real user feedback into a conversion driver — right where shoppers decide.

The takeaway

The digital voice of the customer is now speaking loud and clear in physical stores. With just a few smart placements — a quote, a seal, a star rating — brands can turn every shelf into a source of trust and influence. It’s not just about converting more shoppers. It’s about making every one of them feel heard.

Sources:

https://trustpulse.com/2024/01/07/online-review-statistics/ 

https://lipscore.com/blog/product-reviews-increase-your-online-sales-by-270/#:~:text=Amplify%20Your%20Reviews%20to%20Enhance%20Sales&text=Research%20from%20Bazaarvoice%20found%20that,conversions%20compared%20to%20those%20without  

https://www.aboutamazon.com/news/retail/introducing-amazon-4-star  

https://www.thecommerceshop.com/blog/product-reviews-can-impact-conversion-rate/#:~:text=Displaying%20customer%20feedback%20enhances%20the%20brand%27s%20credibility.&text=Product%20reviews%20increase%20product%20conversion,to%20return%20or%20repeat%20purchases

You might also like:

Join 250+ Happy Try & Review
Customers in Asia

Stay in touch!

Get the latest articles, case studies and news from the world of reviews.


TryandReview.com for brands is a platform that help brands leverage a community of consumers who test products and share reviews.

© 2025 Try & Review Ltd Pte. All rights reserved